What Happened to the Chhitmahals: How India and Bangladesh Swapped 162 Enclaves in 2015

At midnight on 31 July 2015, 162 pieces of land quietly changed countries. A hundred and eleven plots that had been Indian became Bangladeshi, and fifty-one that had been Bangladeshi became Indian. No army moved and nobody had to pack a bag. The land changed hands, the people on it stayed exactly where they were, and by morning there was a different flag over their heads.

About 51,000 people lived on those plots, going by the joint headcount of July 2011. For nearly seven decades most of them had belonged, on paper, to a country that could not reach them while living inside a country that did not count them. Students were registered in schools under false names, and some people bought identity papers from neighbours just so they could travel for work.

This guide sticks to official records, court and Parliament documents, and published research, and where sources disagree it says so. You will see how the enclaves came about (and what historians make of the chess legend), why the fix took 57 years, why the same swap gets quoted with four different totals, why fewer than a thousand people chose to move, and what life looks like in the former enclaves since.

What a chhitmahal actually was

In Bengali, chhit means a scrap or small piece and mahal means land or estate. A chhitmahal is a scrap of land. The English word is enclave: territory of one country that sits entirely inside another.

Before 2015 there were two sets of them. Indian enclaves were scattered across four districts of northern Bangladesh: Panchagarh, Lalmonirhat, Nilphamari and Kurigram. Bangladeshi enclaves lay inside India, mostly in the Cooch Behar district of West Bengal. Some were whole villages. The largest stand-alone Indian enclave, Dasiar Chhara, covered about 6.65 sq km and sat 3 km away from the Indian mainland. Others were barely more than a field.

Then it gets odd, because enclaves could sit inside enclaves. Dahala Khagrabari No. 47 was an Indian enclave inside Bangladesh. Inside it was a Bangladeshi patch called Upan Chowki Bhajni No. 110. And inside that patch was one last Indian plot, Dahala Khagrabari No. 51. So you had Indian land, inside Bangladeshi land, inside Indian land, inside Bangladesh. The plot measured only about 6,880 square metres, close to 1.7 acres, and is described as a jute field owned by a Bangladeshi farmer who lived in the enclave around it.

Diagram showing Dahala Khagrabari No. 51, an Indian plot inside a Bangladeshi enclave inside an Indian enclave inside Bangladesh

Researchers know of no other third-order enclave anywhere in the world. That is why this one field shows up in almost every discussion of the topic, and it is also the short answer to a question many people search: did India and Bangladesh have a third-order enclave? Yes, and it was this plot. It went to Bangladesh in 2015 along with the rest.

Where they came from: a chess legend and a lost treaty

Ask around Cooch Behar and you will hear that the Maharaja of Cooch Behar and a Mughal officer from Rangpur used to play chess for villages, and every lost game moved a village across the line. It is a fun story. Nobody has managed to prove it.

Brendan Whyte, a researcher at the University of Melbourne, spent years on the records and produced a study of more than 500 pages in 2002. He did not find the chess games. Most of the evidence he saw pointed to a peace treaty of 1713 between the Mughal Empire and the kingdom of Cooch Behar, after which some areas passed to the Mughals while landlords on both sides held on to their old estates. No copy of that treaty has turned up, so even this version rests on indirect evidence, and some writers give other years for it.

What is easier to see is how the arrangement worked. A landlord could hold land inside a neighbouring ruler’s territory and still pay his revenue to his own king. Scatter enough of those holdings across a border region and you get a patchwork. The Mughals did not find it strange, and for a long time neither did anyone else. The East India Company seems to have noticed the odd plots only in the nineteenth century. One letter from Rangpur’s magistrate in 1848 is often cited: his police could not enter them, and wanted men hid there. A plan to tidy things up through an exchange in 1932 was dropped after local opposition.

The patchwork became a real problem in 1947. Cooch Behar was a princely state, free to join either new country, and either choice would have left it with enclaves. Many articles blame the Radcliffe line, but Whyte argues the boundary commission had little to do with it. Cooch Behar joined India in 1949, while the Rangpur side sat in East Pakistan. Old tax holdings had turned into pieces of one country stuck inside another.

Living in a place no government could reach

On 15 October 1952, India and Pakistan brought in passports and visas for travel between their eastern halves. For enclave residents the rule was cruel in its detail: their own country was out of reach, and the country around them did not count them as its own. According to a 2018 study in Economic & Political Weekly, by the mid-1950s both governments had more or less stopped trying to run these places, and officials who went in to carry out surveys or censuses were sometimes picked up by the host state’s police.

Day to day, that meant no voting rights, no health centres and no access to the public distribution system. In the Cooch Behar enclaves that ORF studied there were also no schools, markets, electricity or police stations. People told ORF’s researchers that students were registered under false names to get into schools and colleges, and that identity papers were sometimes bought from relatives or neighbours so a person could travel for work. Land was often bought and sold with no registration at all. Legally the residents were not refugees, since they sat on land belonging to their own country, but the term researchers settled on is de facto stateless.

They did not simply wait, though. In the biggest cluster of Indian enclaves in Bangladesh (Dahala Khagrabari, Barapara Khagrabari and Kotbhajni), people elected three citizens’ committees, called Chhitmohol Nagorik Shomiti. The committees acted as courts, organised public works and negotiated with the mainland on the enclaves’ behalf.

Why fixing it took 57 years

The idea was simple enough: swap the pieces so each country holds the land around it. The first agreement to do exactly that was signed in 1958. The exchange happened in 2015.

Timeline of the India Bangladesh enclave exchange from 1949 to the midnight exchange of 31 July 2015

The hard part was legal, not diplomatic. In 1958 the Indian government tried to carry out the Nehru–Noon agreement with an ordinary law. West Bengal’s Assembly unanimously opposed handing over territory, and the President asked the Supreme Court for its opinion. On 14 March 1960 the Court said that giving away territory needs a constitutional amendment. Parliament passed the Ninth Amendment that December, but the transfer it was written for was never carried out in full.

The 1974 agreement between Indira Gandhi and Sheikh Mujibur Rahman went the same way. Bangladesh’s parliament ratified it quickly. India did not, because it also needed an amendment, and that amendment was never passed. Tin Bigha (more on it below) was the one piece of the 1974 deal that moved forward, in 1992.

WhenWhat happened
1949Cooch Behar joins India. Its scattered holdings become Indian land inside East Pakistan, and the reverse.
10 Sep 1958Nehru–Noon agreement: divide Berubari Union and exchange enclaves.
14 Mar 1960Supreme Court: a constitutional amendment is needed to cede territory.
28 Dec 1960Ninth Amendment Act comes into operation, but the Berubari transfer is not completed.
16 May 1974Indira–Mujib Land Boundary Agreement. Ratified by Bangladesh, stuck in India.
6 Sep 2011Manmohan Singh and Sheikh Hasina sign a protocol that revives the deal and adds border strips held by each side.
Dec 2013The amendment Bill is introduced as the 119th. It lapses with the Lok Sabha’s term.
6–7 May 2015Reintroduced Bill passes the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha unanimously.
28 May 2015President signs the Constitution (One Hundredth Amendment) Act.
6 Jun 2015Instruments of ratification exchanged in Dhaka.
6–16 Jul 2015Joint survey of enclave residents by 75 teams.
Midnight, 31 Jul 2015Enclaves change hands.

Why do some pages say the 119th amendment and others the 100th? Because both are right. Constitution amendment Bills are numbered in the order they are introduced, but an Act takes the next free number once it passes. This Bill was introduced as the 119th, yet only 99 amendments had become law by then, so it became the 100th. A leftover “119th” in the text had to be corrected in Parliament the same week. It also explains why the date of ratification is given as 6, 7, 11 or 28 May depending on the step an author has in mind: Rajya Sabha passage, Lok Sabha passage, Rajya Sabha approval of the corrected text, and the President’s assent.

The swap in numbers

Did India give land to Bangladesh in 2015?

Yes, and it received land too, but India gave more than it got. Under the agreement, 111 Indian enclaves with 17,160.63 acres went to Bangladesh, and 51 Bangladeshi enclaves with 7,110.02 acres came to India. Subtract one from the other and India gave up 10,050.61 acres more than it received, which works out to about 40.7 sq km.

A second, smaller swap covered strips of border land that each side already held on the other’s side of the line, known as adverse possession. There India received 2,777.038 acres and handed over 2,267.682 acres, a gain of about 509 acres. Add that in and the overall net comes to roughly 38.6 sq km. Most articles quote “about 40 sq km”, which is the enclaves-only number rounded.

Chart showing 111 Indian enclaves with 17,160.63 acres going to Bangladesh and 51 Bangladeshi enclaves with 7,110.02 acres coming to India

Why the totals never match

Read three articles on this topic and you may meet 162, 198 and 197 for what looks like the same thing. They are counting different things.

What is being countedFigure
Enclaves exchanged under the agreement (official)162 (111 + 51)
Every physical enclave, including counter-enclaves nested inside others (Whyte’s list)198 (106 Indian + 92 Bangladeshi)
Older academic count (van Schendel, 2002)197 (123 Indian + 74 Bangladeshi)

Whyte pointed out that the official 111 and 51 appear to count revenue villages (mauzas) rather than physical enclaves, and one enclave could contain several of them. That alone is enough to explain why the official figure is lower than a count of every separate patch.

People are counted just as loosely. The official joint headcount of July 2011 found 51,549 people: 37,334 in the Indian enclaves and 14,215 in the Bangladeshi ones. A survey by an NGO coalition in 2010 had 37,369 for the Indian enclaves, which is why that number turns up in some places. By the final joint survey in July 2015, 1,582 new names had been added, mostly children born since 2011, and 279 were removed because of deaths. In 2016 the Election Commission worked with about 14,864 people in the 51 former Bangladeshi enclaves. None of these is wrong. They are different dates and different methods.

Why fewer than a thousand people moved

The rules were simple. Residents of the 111 Indian enclaves could become Bangladeshi where they stood or move to India. Residents of the 51 Bangladeshi enclaves had the mirror choice. Seventy-five joint teams carried out a survey from 6 to 16 July 2015, recording each person’s name, age, parents’ names, current citizenship and the citizenship they wanted.

When the survey closed, all of the roughly 15,000 people in the Bangladeshi enclaves had chosen India, and nobody had chosen Bangladesh. In the Indian enclaves, 1,006 of around 39,000 people asked to go to India. The number who actually crossed was lower still. The Home Ministry told the Lok Sabha in March 2018 that 922 people in 201 families had come. You will see 911, 979, 987 and 1,006 in other reports, which come from different dates and different lists.

The expectations had been far higher. West Bengal’s chief minister spoke of 60,000 to 70,000 arrivals, the Centre sized its first rehabilitation package for about 35,000 people, and the External Affairs Minister said estimates ranged from 3,500 to 35,000. ORF cites yet another pre-exchange estimate of about 13,000. The real number was 987 on West Bengal’s list.

Why did so few leave? Researcher Azmeary Ferdoush, who interviewed former enclave residents on the Bangladesh side, found three reasons that fit together. Between 1947 and the late 1960s many families swapped plots among themselves to end up in the country they preferred. Others had built ties to the surrounding land through marriage or by buying land. And by 2015 most residents were second- or third-generation adults who had never known the “home” country. He describes the low number as a choice about where people felt they belonged, not a failure of the survey. A few people did change their minds: twenty who had first opted for India switched back to Bangladesh before the survey closed.

Those who moved could take their belongings and movable property through three exit points, Haldibari, Burimari and Banglabandha, until 30 November 2015. The land they left was recorded by district administrations so the owners could sell it. In India the returnees came in buses arranged by the Indian High Commission in Dhaka, with temporary travel and identity passes. Movement on the Indian side ran from mid-November, with the first arrivals welcomed at Changrabandha on 19 November 2015. Their Bangladeshi money was exchanged for rupees through banks, and they were housed in camps at Dinhata, Mekhliganj and Haldibari.

What changed after midnight

On the Indian side

Roughly 14,000 to 15,000 people in the 51 former Bangladeshi enclaves in Cooch Behar became Indian citizens. The first practical problem was voting. The villages had never been part of any Indian constituency, so Parliament passed the Election Laws (Amendment) Act, in force from 4 March 2016, letting the Election Commission do a limited redrawing of seats in Cooch Behar. On 5 May 2016, 9,776 first-time electors in these areas voted in the West Bengal assembly election, across 38 polling stations. The oldest was a 103-year-old man.

Money was the second. The Centre first announced a package of ₹3,008.89 crore, then on 2 December 2015 the Cabinet approved a scheme of ₹1,005.99 crore over five years from 2015–16, of which ₹898.50 crore was for infrastructure and ₹107.49 crore for rehabilitation and permanent houses for returnees. The package shrank because the number of returnees was far lower than planned.

StageAmount
First announced (May 2015), based on about 35,000 people₹3,008.89 crore
Approved by the Cabinet, 2 Dec 2015₹1,005.99 crore
Released to West Bengal by 28 Feb 2018₹423 crore
Utilisation certificates submitted by then₹260 crore

The money was meant to be spent over 2015–16 to 2019–20, so the 2018 figures are a snapshot, not a final result. ORF researchers who visited Cooch Behar in November 2016 found that residents of one former enclave, Madhya Mashaldanga, still had no electricity, land papers or voter cards a year after the exchange, and that ration and voter cards often carried mistakes in names, ages and even sex. Land was the sharpest worry: without papers, people were unsure of their claim to the plots they farmed. A 2022 essay in Refugee Watch argues that many former enclave residents are still waiting for services most villages take for granted.

On the Bangladeshi side

Most of the roughly 37,000 people in the 111 former Indian enclaves became Bangladeshi citizens without moving. According to Ferdoush, Bangladesh’s more centralised administration made it quicker to bring the new areas into the system, and the Ministry of Land set up a special, faster process to register enclave land. A 2023 study of 100 households in Debiganj, Panchagarh, found that human, social, natural, physical and financial assets had all improved after citizenship, though most households still fell below the poverty line the authors used and satisfaction with local institutions was only moderate.

ORF’s own comparison, a year after the exchange, leaned the same way: newspaper reports from Bangladesh spoke of electricity, roads, clinics and schools reaching former enclaves, while reports from the Indian side were full of disappointment. Both sides saw the legal change come fast. Roads, jobs and services came slower.

The one enclave that is still there

One piece was left out of the 2015 swap on purpose. Under the 1974 deal, India kept the southern half of South Berubari Union No. 12 and Bangladesh kept two Bangladeshi enclaves inside India, Dahagram and Angarpota, together about 18.7 sq km (4,617 acres). Reports put its population somewhere between 16,000 and 20,000.

The two are joined to the Bangladeshi mainland by the Tin Bigha corridor, a strip of Indian land 178 metres long and 85 metres wide that India leases to Bangladesh in perpetuity under the 1974 agreement. Since the corridor links it to the mainland, you will see Dahagram–Angarpota called an exclave rather than a true enclave.

The corridor opened on 26 June 1992, but only for six hours a day. From July 1996 it was open for twelve hours. After the 6 September 2011 agreement it opened for 24 hours, and Bangladesh’s prime minister declared it open on 19 October 2011 along with a new hospital and a union council complex for the enclave.

Two border questions people ask next

What is a zero line?

The zero line is the actual line of the international boundary. Under the 1975 Joint India–Bangladesh Guidelines for Border Authorities, neither side should build defence structures within 150 yards of it. Where India has put up barbed-wire fencing on flat ground, the fence usually stands about 150 yards inside Indian territory, and the strip between the fence and the zero line is the area people call no man’s land. Farmers who own land there are generally the only people allowed through. The rule has exceptions in places where the terrain made it hard to follow.

Why is Bangladesh almost surrounded by India?

Because of the way Bengal was divided in 1947. The Radcliffe line, published on 17 August 1947, gave the Muslim-majority eastern part of Bengal to Pakistan as East Pakistan. That area became Bangladesh in 1971 and kept the same boundary. As a result Bangladesh shares a 4,096 km land border with India on its west, north and east, a short 271 km border with Myanmar in the southeast, and the Bay of Bengal to the south.

Sources and further reading

Official documents and published research used for this article. Where sources gave different figures, the article names the date and the source.

Last checked on 14 November 2026. Figures for returnees, population and money spent are tied to the dates given above and may be revised in later official documents.

Leave a Comment